We all want our favorite Best Butter Dish to be at the right consistency so that we can enjoy it, not only during breakfast but also when we’re cooking our favorite home recipes.
There’s an old debate about whether butter should be refrigerated to keep it from perishing quickly, or just be kept at room temperature so that it doesn’t get too cold and hard, which most of us find troublesome.
In this article, I’m going to show you the best butter dishes for storing your butter that you can buy right now, as well as give you information on how to keep your butter fresh.
Best Butter Dish On The 2023 Market
OXO Good Grips Butter Dish – Budget Pick
[amazon box= “B00L9X6M6I”]
Aside from being the budget pick for this list, the OXO Good Grips Butter Dish is also the best-reviewed butter dish on this list, and it’s relatively easy to figure out why.
This butter dish accommodates every type of long and short butter sticks and has a clear lid that lies on the dish itself, that’s easy to remove and keeps the butter from sliding off the dish during transport.
Personally, I like the overall construction of this butter dish.
It’s designed to make the butter not slip off of it and soil the lid. I also like how it has convenient tablespoon measurement markings that serve as a guide for cutting the butter.
That’s entirely convenient and efficient, especially for people who like to cut their butter into equal servings for the whole family.
OXO also backs it with a 100% satisfaction guarantee that will let you return the product for replacement or refund if, for some unbelievable reason, you don’t find this butter dish suitable for you.
To sum things up, the OXO Good Grips Butter Dish is one the best, feature-packed butter dishes you can get for a meager price.
- Accommodates every type of short and long butter sticks
- Easy to remove clear lid which also keeps butter from sliding off the dish
- Convenient tablespoon measurement markings
- Stoppers on either sides to keep butter in place
- Comes with a 100% satisfaction-guarantee.
- Some consumers comment on how the lid doesn’t stay on.
KooK Ceramic Butter Dish – Runner Up
[amazon box= “B075RJ5B2V”]
Most people nowadays would cringe when you tell them that something’s made from China, and that’s largely due to the baseless stigma that surrounds China-made products in general.
But in truth, some of the best products in the world are manufactured and distributed by China, and I’d like to assure you that I’m not being paid to tell you this.
I just want things to be clear since this superb, China-made butter keeper is the runner-up on this list of the best butter dishes.
The Kook Ceramic Butter Dish fits most standard size butter sticks and has a handle cover design with the word “Butter” on it.
People might think that’s pretty lame, but I beg to differ.
I think it’s actually brilliant, not only because it lets people know what’s precisely on the dish, but also because it adds to the overall aesthetics of the butter dish.
Things made of ceramic are always good to have. It reminds me of vintage kitchenware and utensils from the middle ages, and those are the kind of things that I’d love to add to my kitchen collection.
Going back, this butter dish is rather practical. Besides being pleasing to the eye, it, being made of ceramic, helps a lot when it comes to keeping the temperature inside the butter dish. That means you don’t have to worry about the butter losing its consistency when you leave it on the counter.
Also, this butter dish is a great holder for cheeses and chocolates, and that’s the kind of versatility we all need from our kitchenware. To put it simply, the Kook Ceramic Butter Dish is one of the best butter dishes you can buy right now for storing your butter, and at a reasonable price.
- Handle cover for easy lifting
- Nice design
- Easy to clean
- Can also store cheese and chocolates.
- Some consumers find the butter dish rough to the touch.
Sweese 3150 Butter Dish – Editor’s Pick
[amazon box= “B072QCSZZ7”]
Now we’ve come to my pick for this list!
I must say that this one’s on an entirely different level than the rest, which is precisely the reason why I picked it as the winner of this list.
If you think I’m exaggerating, I’m telling you right now that I’m going to prove you otherwise.
The Sweese 3150 Butter Dish is actually an updated version of a previous butter dish from Sweese. It has a rather deep interior that helps stop the butter from sticking to the lid, preventing it from going with the cover when you open the dish.
Also, the deep interior allows you to store two butter sticks in it, so you can use one butter stick while the other is still softening up.
The porcelain container is rather sleek, and it’s much more durable than plastic. Though plastic can get the job done, porcelain actually does a better job when it comes to holding the butter, and keeping it in the right temperature.
And the best part about this butter dish? Its lid.
The lid is made of beech, a robust kind of hardwood with a close straight grain which makes it incredibly sturdy.
Beechwood often ages gracefully unlike synthetic materials, which means it’ll retain its appearance even after many years.
Also, it doubles as a compact cutting board for slicing. You can use it as a butter cutting board, or a cutting board for small fruits and vegetables.
The butter dish itself is actually quite versatile, as you can use it as a tool caddy or toiletry holder once you buy a new butter dish.
I can’t really think of another butter dish that can give so much value to one’s money!
Overall, the Sweese 3150 Butter Dish is the best butter dish available for you to buy right now, and trust me when I say that it’s a must-add tool to your kitchen!
- Deep interior allows storage of up to two butter sticks
- Made of food-grade porcelain
- Can serve as a tool caddy or toiletry holder
- Lid made of robust beech wood
- Lid doubles as a cutting board for slicing.
- Some consumers find the lid doesn’t fit properly with the butter dish.
ROSCHER Ceramic Butter Dish – Luxury Pick
[amazon box= “B07C37M9VC”]
If you’re looking for a butter dish that can also serve as a decoration for your kitchen counter, you might want to consider this butter dish. This one’s my luxury pick for this list, and every penny in its price tag is justified. You can take my word for it.
The ROSCHER Ceramic Butter Dish is another butter dish on this list that’s made of ceramic, with a small, rectangular cover that matches the dish itself.
It has appealing midnight colors that can capture anyone’s attention. It combines both modern and retro designs that add a clean look to most contemporary kitchens.
But beyond its design, I love how this ceramic butter dish can keep butter to a consistency where it can be spread liberally to my toast while still being able to hold its shape firmly.
The two-piece butter dish serving plate and lid are made of food-grade ceramic that’s durable, non-stick, and dishwasher safe, and it can store a single, long stick of butter.
With a reasonable price, l have a butter dish that performs efficiently while serving as a decorative piece that’s versatile enough to be a cheese holder.
The ROSCHER Ceramic Butter Dish is an ideal butter dish for those who want to add a piece of kitchenware that doubles as a decorative piece to make their kitchen more elegant-looking.
- Made of professional-grade ceramic
- Excellent in keeping butter fresh and keep its consistency
- Can serve as a decorative piece
- Appealing midnight colors that’s pleasing to the eye.
- Some consumers find this butter dish a bit short.
LA JOLIE MUSE Butter Dish – Best-Designed Butter Dish
[amazon box= “B01L18BUGW”]
The previous butter dish may have a great design, but when it comes to overall aesthetics, this butter dish is undisputedly the best.
I seriously think that this butter dish is the best-designed butter dish that you can buy right now, especially if you’re someone who appreciates elegant designs.
I didn’t include this butter dish solely because of its design though.
The LA JOLIE MUSE Butter Dish is a decorative, ceramic butter dish that’s excellent when it comes to storing your favorite butter.
I’ve personally purchased this one, and I must say that it’s one of the best purchases I’ve made when it comes to my kitchenware collection. It has a vintage design that fits most contemporary-style kitchens and is sure to capture your visitors’ attention, thanks to its intricate details.
I’ve always imagined eating breakfast with my most favorite, vintage kitchenware collection, and this butter dish made that possible.
It does an excellent job when it comes to keeping butter in the right consistency for spreading over toast, or for topping over pancakes. I love how it helps butter retain its shape and texture for long periods.
While the butter dish is outstanding enough, the lid is rather exceptional in its own way. Thanks to the hexagonal handle and the bronze seal engraved with the word “butter” enclosed in an intricate, flowery pattern, the whole butter dish set permeates an air sophistication of the highest level.
Not only does it look beautiful and does an excellent job of storing butter, but it’s versatile enough to serve as a vegetable plate or a biscuit plate.
The LA JOLIE MUSE Butter Dish is a must-buy butter dish for those who like a butter dish that’s efficient, convenient, and elegantly-designed all at the same time.
- Efficient in keeping butter fresh
- Vintage design
- Can serve as a decorative piece
- Lid with hexagonal handle and bronze seal with elegant engravings
- Can store standard size butter sticks.
- Some consumers comment on how the pictures look better than the actual product.
Reasons Why You Should Use A Butter Dish
The purpose of butter dishes are pretty straightforward, but in case you’re unsure whether getting a butter dish would be a good kitchen upgrade for you, allow us to give you reasons on why you should start using a butter dish as early as now:
Keeps Your Butter Fresh Without Refrigeration
You read that right.
Butter dishes keep your butter fresh even without refrigeration. Butter dishes is a great storage option if your refrigerator doesn’t have space for your favorite butter.
Thanks to their construction, butter dishes usually do an excellent job when it comes to keeping the butter cool and fresh after you take it out of the refrigerator.
Also, it keeps away disgusting lurkers such as vermin from snatching your precious butter.
Allows Butter To Soften Without Losing Consistency
Butter dishes are a two-piece set for an excellent reason.
They make a practically airtight enclosure that maintains the temperature around your butter, allowing it to gradually soften while keeping its consistency, although that’s partly thanks to butter having a relatively low water content.
I don’t know about you, but I definitely love my butter soft and at the right consistency so that my toast won’t break apart when I spread it over, like when it does with butter right out of the fridge.
Serves As A Decorative Piece For Your Counter
You might think this sounds trivial, but there are a lot of us that actually appreciate kitchenware for their decorative value.
It’s also precisely the reason why some people, such as myself, like to collect kitchenware.
In case you failed to notice (which I highly doubt), a couple of the best butter dishes on my list doubles as decorative pieces. Although to be fair, each of the other butter dishes has a good design.
But I think you get the point.
Some people take butter dishes seriously, while some don’t. Kidding aside, if you’re fond of collecting kitchenware with decorative value, it’s high time you take a good look at the best butter dishes on this list.
Can Also Be Used For Other Things
Butter dishes aren’t only efficient when it comes to storing butter.
They can also be used for other things, which is the kind of versatility other kitchenware, and other things, in general, should possess.
Aside from storing butter, butter dishes can also store other goods like cheese and chocolates, but it doesn’t stop there. You can even store spare onions, garlic, and other small vegetables for that matter, while you’re at it.
My top pick for this list of the best butter dish, for example, is so versatile that it can give you great value for your money.
The butter dish itself can serve as a tool caddy and toiletry holder after it’s served its original purpose, while its lid, made of beech wood, doubles as a cutting board for slicing.
Well, you get the picture.
Butter dishes are a useful tool for keeping butter fresh without refrigeration.
The Sweese 3150 Butter Dish is my top pick for this list of the best butter dishes because of its overall efficiency in keeping butter fresh and its convenient features, especially its lid, which doubles as a cutting board for slicing.
I hope that this article helped you in choosing the right butter dish for you, and as always, you know I love to hear from you, so if you have questions, feedback, or suggestions, simply leave a comment down below, and I’d be happy to address it as soon as I can!
Jen Lin-Liu is the founder of Black Sesame Kitchen. A Chinese-American writer and a nationally certified Chinese chef in Beijing. Jen is the author of two memoirs, Serve the People: A Stir-Fried Journey Through China and On the Noodle Road: From Beijing to Rome with Love and Pasta.